“I shall never use profanity except in discussing house rent and taxes.”
– Mark Twain
I just read 100 comments posted on the Yahoo News site in response to a recent article about “tax excuses the IRS won’t buy”. Good place to vent with a few intelligent posts, and one made me laugh out loud: “I’ve changed my name to General Electric so I don’t have to pay taxes for 2010.” Funny in a dark way. Funny in a way that makes us groan inside.
GE made 14 billion in profits in 2010, didn’t pay a dollar in taxes, and got their PR machine to defend this unbelievable fact with data about their write-offs being connected to helping the environment. Lots of technical things GE does with energy allow them to skirt taxes because of their contribution to helping the planet’s environment and working towards renewable energy sources. Great idea. Heart-felt applause. No, really.
In practice, however, PLU’s (people like us) gasp in anger and contempt. For the record, thank you GE for trying to make the world a better place and thank you for employing people. But if that is a criteria, then what about teachers, moms, coaches, therapists, artists, entrepreneurs, or restaurateurs? We make the world a better place, and we don’t see oodles of loopholes waiting for us at our CPA’s. Ok, yeah we do. We look for ways to creatively account our line items towards paying less taxes. Guilty as charged. And that’s the problem. We are ALL looking for a way out, and we are ALL very good at rationalizing this.
Perhaps this problem can be balanced out by imposing an extra tax on professions whose livelihoods do not contribute to the planet. Stock brokers, for example, or companies that create pollution (BP: are you listening?) will have to pay a special tax for their blood-sucking work. (A personal apology to all the financial planners with skills to help us! You would be exempt.)
Furthermore, another solution can be found via the flat tax. This argument has not worked thus far, according to one venting post: “the only reason why the flat tax favored by the MAJORITY of Americans will not fly is because all the lawyers and others who benefit from translating tax laws will be out of business – and their lobby will not stand for it.” This resonates as true. Perhaps another reason why the flat tax approach has not yet happened is because it makes too much sense. Heaven forbid we do something intelligent and fair. Where are Flat Tax Lobbyists and Flat Tax Political Candidates when we need them most? Help.
Taxes are a privilege to pay as well. Don’t forget your local library (if it hasn’t yet closed due to lack of funding!). Don’t dismiss local pools, hospitals, and freeways. If we privatize everything, what will happen when food and water shortages happen (in our lifetime, according to scientists), and PLU’s don’t have the funds to cover these extra costs? Laissez-faire capitalism is alive and well in the world, contrary to popular news, and this is the path the planet seems to be taking: privatize the planet and eat the poor.
Currently, I am officially living below the poverty level, although I live a middle-class lifestyle. This is changing as my financial/employment situation is about to take a positive turn. I just sent W-2 and W-4 forms to my CPA since I worked both as an employee and as an independent contractor (sole-proprietor business ownership) in 2010. I made … drum roll… 13K and lived off the last of my savings (my investments are gone). Thank goodness I have a natural talent for living frugally (and no house or kids to support). This same story is being told with different plot twists all over the country. And we are tired… but still hopeful. This is the strength of human resilience.
Curious about what the IRS will say about my situation, I did some research about PLU’s. I found out that I am still too rich to get help or a break. The main reasons are:
- I still own a car.
- I still pay all my bills on time.
- I still have a credit rating that is low risk for lending institutions.
So if I stop paying my bills on time, get rid of my car, and let my credit score slip into oblivion, I will then officially be living in the poverty belt where help is available. Metaphorically speaking, my situation is classic in which I have fallen through the cracks of the system. The only thing keeping me from really going under is fear. The good kind. The kind that makes me wake up everyday, and start from zero. It’s a new day.
Personally, I have never felt cheated by paying taxes. Instead, it is a privilege of living in society with luxuries such as cars and roads to drive them on. At the same time, the waste of money in this country alone is appalling (private and public equally), our roads suck, our police forces are corrupt, and don’t even get the conversation started on the public school system. Shame on us. All governments and all businesses are either run well or not, mostly not. I don’t adhere to the current American climate that is polarized into actually believing that all governments are good/bad, and all businesses are good/bad. They are all run by humans, and are therefore intrinsically flawed. Yep, I’m mad as hell as much as the next guy. But…
I am still not willing to NOT pay taxes for a society that somehow works. Kinda. I wonder if General Electric understands this. I think not. Shame on them, too.
For more info: www.VeloCityCoachingServices.com
A great CPA firm: www.mhccpas.com